7 Comments
User's avatar
Naomi Morse's avatar

I was very skeptical of those saying that Democrats could suddenly pull 15-30 more blue districts out of a hat in a short time frame. I worked very hard to get Michigan's independent redistricting commission established, and I still believe it was the right way to go for our state, but as I learn more about proportional representation, I believe that should be our long-term goal, and I'll be working with others on that important reform.Thank you for sharing your perspective, which I always learn from.

Debra McDonough's avatar

Thanks for another accessable description of the problem. Please check the "mystery token" description. Pretty sure that you mean one "mystery token" in each of 9 buckets?

Vivian Unger's avatar

Great piece. Things are awful, but we can still laugh about it. Or at least smile wryly. And that helps, doesn't it?

I recently read that the Fair Representation Act was just reintroduced. I think for the 5th time. It probably doesn't have much hope under the current administration... but then the previous administration did nothing with it either.

How do we get the Democrats to care about saving democracy? Do we all have to withhold our donations until they prioritize it? (I'm already doing that.)

Active Voice's avatar

Fun article. I favor multi-member districts. Do we need to take the Voting Rights Act into account though? The idea of majority-minority districts kind of goes out the window with most multi-member districts, no?

Putney D.'s avatar

It's looking increasingly likely majority-minority districts and what's left of the VRA will be struck down by the Supreme Court next year so...

Seth Scott's avatar

I think it would be better to make all those redistricting commissions in blue and purple states change their target to make the national house map fair. As an example that would make it so that if the Texas map creates 5 new r seats California would make 5 d seats as a response. This would put pressure on places like Texas not to do what their doing because their own effort to cheat the map would be countered by redistricting commissions elsewhere but if they don’t do it the commission won’t. Elections should matter more than the map.

Joe's avatar

Illinois maximum gerrymandered? I've seen what I thought were credible all-dem gerrymanders. https://x.com/USA_Polling/status/1950614085462053176