Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nick Pharris's avatar

Arizona didn’t “pioneer” redistricting by commission in 2000!

Washington’s bipartisan commission began in prototype form in 1983 and has operated in its present form since 1991.

https://www.redistricting.wa.gov/history-of-redistricting.html

Gettaway Gal's avatar

1/ SCOTUS did not “gut” the voting Rights Act but, rather, attempted to restore its original meaning (and I say “attempted” solely because they did not go far enough). FWIW, it is demeaning to assume that all members of a particular racial classification share the same values and would automatically vote for the same candidates (I reside in a state where we have significant racial diversity in our congressional ranks and it does not conform to the racial composition of particular districts - for example, we have a Latino congressman representing a majority white district). 2/ While I agree we should change the rules of districting, I am concerned about a change that would make the two-party system a permanent fixture - at present, IMO, neither major party deserves my unwavering support and I would like to have more choice. For that reason, IMO, the better change would be to fix put a cap on the number of residents who can be included in a district - which would result in a significant expansion of the number of congressional representatives (as envisioned by, for example, George Washington) and require the result you say you are looking for, meaning candidates would have to actually know their constituents and win them over (one of the big problems now is the influence of outside money which, under the present system, can be concentrated and targeted, resulting in the most partisan candidates advancing through the primaries who are beholden to the partisan interests that support them, depriving many, if not most, of us voters from having a meaningful choice).

3 more comments...

Ready for more?